Miles: Seems to be the only person on the island with some common fucking sense. Part of me thinks that he's right and that blowing the nuke core is going to cause the incident. Minly because ALL OF THIS ALREADY HAPPENED. Ellie already knew she was going to shoot her son in the present and Ricardus knew about Jack and the rest in the present.
Rose and Bernard: I was right about that one too. They were, as I said, "off somewhere doing something". Certainly not the most inelegant solution they could have come up with to explain where the characters were. I was just glad that they showed up, as anyone who reads my postings knows I hate the loose ends.
Jacob: Is kind of like a white Bagger Vance. He's winkingly prescient and says things that seem vague to the characters. At the same time having him show up as another immortal with nebulous powers that just shows up and buys NKOTB lunch boxes and chocolate is a tad weak in my mind. It was cute to see that he had always been affecting the characters lives. At the same time it seems like they tacked this on. And for an immortal he kind of went out like a bit of a bitch. For the record, that is not how you convince someone to, um, not stab you to death. But, that wasn't the most troubling thing by far...
The Bad Twin: The second they opened that box I knew that it was going to be Locke's dead body. Because, well, what the fuck wlse could it be? It's a bunch of Drive Shaft Cds? Me thinks not. So, yeah, there's an evil John Locke who is that guy from the first five minutes of the episode. Okay. Honestly, the thing kind of smacks of poor writing. Yes, I get that there have been broad strokes of duality metaphors throughout the show. From the pretty on the nose black and white references made in season one to the many role reversals on the show. I get that thematically you can pull this sort of thing. My problem is that it is a cheap trick. Yes, they prefaced the whole "it's impossible that Locke got resurrected" angle on the show. But...the show's already fantastical with its immortals, smoke monsters and reappearing dead cast members. And it's a cheap trick because it's some dude that has probably been mentioned on the show in passing who is now integral to the plot, but has just been introduced out of left field. And that's my problem. And yes it's because I didn't see it coming. Reason being, nobody could have seen it coming because it is so left field. It also states that the shows whole man of science v. man of faith debate is everybody wins. The peanut butter is in the chocolate, dogs and cats living together, mass hysteria. Oh, and he too is also, probably the smoke monster. Think about it take a second. He set Locke up to die so he could assume his form as he can come back as the dead on the island. Smokey told Ben to listen to Locke. Locke was certainly not in the room with Ben. That nameless dude hated interlopers on the island. Smokey kills interlopers on the island. He's security for the island because he kills all of the people coming to taint it. Bong (imagine Jason Mewes saying it. The word bong not the rest of it.) Fun Side note: people on the interwebs have been callin him the dark man so, new guess, the smoke monster is none other then Randall Flagg...or Liam Neeson (go rent the movie).
The Incident: Miles is probably right. That's how time travel works. The 77 characters remember them happening. In 07 it had already happened. Farraday is probably playing the castaways from beyond the grave. Or he realized that the only way to course correct was to have this happen becuse it always happened that way. Think about it. Take a second.
Season Six Predictions: I can't predict with 100% certainty if I'm right about the plane crashing anyway. If it doesn't crash they'll still be on the island because as any sci-fi fan knows: when you change the past you actually create an alternate earth. Because what happened in your reality to get you back into time to change it had to have happened lest you create a reality crashing paradox. Also, the island exists outside of the Earth's space time (read my baby theory in an old post it explains it well, and I already wrote it). Um, what else, good John Locke will come back...somehow. Ben never saw Jacob because his resurrection in the temple was done with the evil juju. The band will get back together. And, they'll probably spend the rest of their days there. If the plane doesn't crash they'll have no world to go back to as there will be, um, themselves living their lives in their stead. If the plane doesn't crash my big prediction for the end of the show is thus: adult Aaron and Ji Yeon and a crew of explorers, scientists and the like show back up to the isalnd and the game begins again. This time the Dark Man is Ben and Jacob has been replaced by John Locke (cue sound effect and fade to black). I may be the only person I know that still watches the show...probably not.
Season Five reflections: Much like Final Crisis I feel that they were doing something incredibly interesting and thought provoking, for the respective mediums of big 2 in continuity super hero books and network television, and then totally dropped the ball at the end. Mainly because in both cases they brought gigantic plot elements, that fit thematically but are not explicitly mentioned or aluded to, in at the end in a manner that is totally unsatisfying. I mean both the comic and the season had last second all encompassing evil characters. And my reaction to both has been a slight cringe. I've gone back and reread Final Crisis and enjoyed most of it. And I'm sure when I get my Season Five Blu-ray I'll enjoy ninety percent of it too, but damn. That's all really.